Ten problems on the length of a curve and the area of a surface of revolution: a line checked against the distance formula, y = x^(3/2), the catenary, a curve built so that 1 + (y′)² is a perfect square, arc length in y, a circular arc that gives back the angle, y = x² by trig substitution, the sphere's 4πr², √x turned about the x-axis and x² turned about the y-axis, with worked solutions and the mistakes of taking the square root term by term, leaving out the slant factor and measuring the radius from the wrong axis.
Before you start
The length of a curve is found the same way as an area: cut it into tiny pieces, approximate each piece by something simple, and add. For a curve, the simple thing is a short straight segment, and Pythagoras gives its length. Turning the curve around an axis sweeps each segment into a thin band, and adding the bands gives the area of the surface. The formulas are short, but the square root in them rarely has an antiderivative, so the problems that can be done by hand are the ones where 1+(y′)2 turns out to be a perfect square, or where a substitution clears it. The work goes wrong in a few places: the square root split term by term, the derivative taken in the wrong variable, the slant factor left out of a surface area, the radius measured from the wrong axis, and the disk formula used for a surface. These ten problems cover each of them.
Arc length. For y=f(x) on ,[a,b],.L=∫ab1+f′(x)2dx. For x=g(y) on ,[c,d],,L=∫cd1+g′(y)2dy, with the derivative and the limits both in .y.
Where it comes from. A short piece of curve is nearly straight, with length .ds=dx2+dy2=1+(dy/dx)2dx.
Perfect squares. If f′(x)=A−B with ,4AB=1, then 1+f′2=(A+B)2 and .1+f′2=A+B. Curves like 6x3+2x1 are built this way.
Surface area. Turning a curve about an axis gives ,S=∫2πrds, where r is the distance from the curve to the axis. About the x-axis ;r=∣y∣; about the y-axis .r=∣x∣.
Checks. A sphere of radius r has area ,4πr2, and an arc of a circle of radius r through angle θ has length .rθ. An arc length is never shorter than the straight chord between its ends, and a surface area has units of length squared.
Find the length of y=2x+1 from x=0 to x=3 with the arc length integral, and check it with the distance formula.
·
Find the length of y=x3/2 from x=0 to .x=4.
··
The hanging-cable curve .y=coshx=2ex+e−x. Find its length from x=0 to .x=ln2.
··
Find the length of y=6x3+2x1 from x=1 to .x=2.
··
Find the length of the curve x=32(y−1)3/2 from y=1 to .y=4.
··
Find the length of y=1−x2 from x=0 to ,x=21, and explain the answer with a picture.
···
Find the length of the parabola y=x2 from x=0 to .x=1.
·
Turn the semicircle ,y=r2−x2,,−r≤x≤r, about the x-axis, and find the surface area of the sphere.
··
Find the area of the surface made by turning ,y=x,,0≤x≤2, about the x-axis.
···
Find the area of the surface made by turning ,y=x2,,0≤x≤1, about the y-axis.
Answers
35≈6.708
278(1010−1)≈9.073
sinh(ln2)=22−21=43
1217≈1.417
32(8−1)=314≈4.667
6π≈0.5236
L=25+41ln(2+5)≈1.4789
S=4πr2
S=313π≈13.614
S=6π(55−1)≈5.330
Worked solutions
Problem 1
Find the length of y=2x+1 from x=0 to x=3 with the arc length integral, and check it with the distance formula.
,y′=2, so 1+y′2=5A line has constant slope.
L=∫035dx=35The integrand is a constant.
The ends are (0,1) and ,(3,7), at distance 32+62=45=35The two agree.
35≈6.708For a line, the arc length formula is the distance formula.
Problem 2
Find the length of y=x3/2 from x=0 to .x=4.
,y′=23x1/2, so 1+y′2=1+49xSquare the derivative.
L=∫04(1+49x)1/2dxSubstitute ,u=1+49x,;du=49dx;u runs from 1 to .10.
=94⋅32[u3/2]110=278(103/2−1)The power rule in .u.
278(1010−1)≈9.073The chord from (0,0) to (4,8) has length ,80≈8.944, a little shorter.
Problem 3
The hanging-cable curve .y=coshx=2ex+e−x. Find its length from x=0 to .x=ln2.
y′=sinhx=2ex−e−xDifferentiate each exponential.
1+sinh2x=cosh2xExpand: ,1+4e2x−2+e−2x=4e2x+2+e−2x, a perfect square.
L=∫0ln2coshxdx=sinh(ln2)−sinh0,coshx>0, so the square root is coshx itself.
sinh(ln2)=22−21=43eln2=2 and .e−ln2=21.
Problem 4
Find the length of y=6x3+2x1 from x=1 to .x=2.
y′=2x2−2x21Differentiate term by term.
1+y′2=1+4x4−21+4x41=4x4+21+4x41=(2x2+2x21)2The middle term of y′2 is ,−2⋅2x2⋅2x21=−21, and adding 1 flips its sign.
L=∫12(2x2+2x21)dx=[6x3−2x1]12The square root is gone.
=(68−41)−(61−21)=1213+31Evaluate at both limits.
1217≈1.417The curve was chosen so that 1+y′2 is a square; most curves are not so kind.
Problem 5
Find the length of the curve x=32(y−1)3/2 from y=1 to .y=4.
dydx=(y−1)1/2The curve is given as x in terms of ,y, so differentiate in .y.
1+(dydx)2=1+(y−1)=yThe square root will be .y.
L=∫14ydy=32[y3/2]14The limits are values of .y.
32(8−1)=314≈4.667Solving for y and integrating in x would have given the same length with a much harder integral.
Problem 6
Find the length of y=1−x2 from x=0 to ,x=21, and explain the answer with a picture.
,y′=1−x2−x, so 1+y′2=1−x21−x2+x2=1−x21A common denominator.
L=∫01/21−x2dx=arcsin21−arcsin0A standard antiderivative.
=6π.sin6π=21.
6π≈0.5236The curve is the unit circle, and the arc from (0,1) to (21,23) subtends an angle of 6π at the center. On a circle of radius ,1, arc length is the angle.
Problem 7
Find the length of the parabola y=x2 from x=0 to .x=1.
L=∫011+4x2dx.y′=2x. This one is not a perfect square.
,x=21tanθ,,dx=21sec2θdθ,;1+4x2=secθ;θ runs from 0 to arctan2Trig substitution for .1+(2x)2.
L=21∫0arctan2sec3θdθ=41[secθtanθ+ln∣secθ+tanθ∣]0arctan2The standard integral of ,sec3, done by parts.
At ,θ=arctan2,tanθ=2 and secθ=5The triangle with opposite 2 and adjacent .1.
L=25+41ln(2+5)≈1.4789Between the chord 2≈1.4142 and the path along the axes, .2.
Problem 8
Turn the semicircle ,y=r2−x2,,−r≤x≤r, about the x-axis, and find the surface area of the sphere.
ds=1+y′2dx=r2−x2rdxAs in Problem 6, with radius :r:.1+y′2=r2−x2r2.
2πyds=2πr2−x2⋅r2−x2rdx=2πrdxThe radius y cancels the square root.
S=∫−rr2πrdx=2πr⋅2rA constant integrand.
S=4πr2Every slice of the sphere of the same thickness dx has the same area, ,2πrdx, wherever it is cut: Archimedes' hat-box theorem.
Problem 9
Find the area of the surface made by turning ,y=x,,0≤x≤2, about the x-axis.
,y′=2x1, so 1+y′2=1+4x1The slant factor.
2πy1+y′2=2πx1+4x1=2πx+41Multiply under one square root.
S=2π∫02(x+41)1/2dx=34π[(x+41)3/2]02The power rule.
=34π(827−81)=34π⋅413(49)3/2=827 and .(41)3/2=81.
S=313π≈13.614The surface is a paraboloid, open at the wide end.
Problem 10
Find the area of the surface made by turning ,y=x2,,0≤x≤1, about the y-axis.
The distance from the point (x,x2) to the y-axis is ,x, so r=xAbout the y-axis, the radius is horizontal.
S=∫012πx1+4x2dxds=1+4x2dx as in Problem 7.
,u=1+4x2,:du=8xdx:S=82π∫15u1/2du=4π⋅32[u3/2]15This time the x in the radius makes the substitution work.
S=6π(55−1)≈5.330A bowl: like the surface in Problem 9 it is a paraboloid, but here its axis is the y-axis, the axis of turning.
Where this goes wrong
1. Taking the square root term by term
1+y′2 looks as if it should simplify to .1+y′.
1+y′2=1+49x for y=x3/2Right so far: Problem 2, step 1.
“.1+49x=1+23x.”The habit that causes the mistake: a square root split across a sum.
L=∫04(1+23x)dx=4+8=12;a+b=a+b; squaring 1+23x gives an extra .3x. The length is .9.073. The 12 is exactly the path along the axes, :4+8: integrating 1+y′ adds the horizontal distance to the vertical one.
2. Using dy/dx when the integral is in y
The arc length formula is remembered with dy/dx in it, whatever the variable.
x=32(y−1)3/2 from y=1 to y=4Right so far: Problem 5.
“,dxdy=y−11, so the integrand is .1+y−11.”The habit that causes the mistake: the reciprocal derivative used with .dy.
L=∫14y−1ydy=23+arsinh3≈4.781With dy outside, the inside needs :(dydx)2: then 1+(y−1)=y and .L=314≈4.667. The wrong answer is close enough to look right.
3. Leaving out the slant factor
Surface area gets set up like a volume by shells or disks: 2πr times .dx.
r=x about the x-axis, 0≤x≤2Right so far: Problem 9.
“.S=∫022πxdx.”The habit that causes the mistake: the band's width taken as dx instead of .ds.
S=2π⋅32⋅23/2=382π≈11.848Where the curve is steep, a band of width dx is much wider along the surface. The width is ,ds=1+y′2dx, and the area is .313π≈13.614.
4. Measuring the radius from the wrong axis
2πyds gets used for every surface.
ds=1+4x2dx for y=x2Right so far: Problem 10, step 2.
“.S=∫012πyds=∫012πx21+4x2dx.”The habit that causes the mistake: y is the radius only about the x-axis.
S≈3.810That is the surface made by turning the curve about the x-axis, a different, narrower horn. About the y-axis each point travels on a circle of radius ,x, and the area is .6π(55−1)≈5.330.
5. Using the disk formula for a surface
Volumes of revolution use ,πr2, and the habit carries over.
y=r2−x2 and ds=r2−x2rdxRight so far: Problem 8, step 1.
“.S=∫πy2ds.”The habit that causes the mistake: the area of a disk where the circumference of a band belongs.
S=∫−rrπrr2−x2dx=2π2r3An r3 is a volume, not an area, which is the quickest check that the setup is wrong; for r=1 it gives 4.935 instead of .4π≈12.566. A band of radius y has circumference ,2πy, and .∫2πyds=4πr2.